
The history of pearls is a testament to their enduring allure and cultural significance. As one of the oldest known
gemstones, pearls have been revered across civilizations for their natural beauty and rarity.
Their evolution from ancient treasures to modern fashion staples reflects changes in societal values, technological
advancements, and global trade dynamics.
This guide delves into the multifaceted journey of pearls, exploring their historical importance, cultural symbolism,
and the factors that have shaped their popularity over time.
Table of Contents
- Historical Significance of Pearls
- Global Influence
- Different Types of Pearls and Their Origins
- Major Pearl Harvesting Regions
- Pearl Cultivation Over Time
- Pearls in Art and Literature
- Perception of Pearls in Modern Times
- Pearls Become Popular in Fashion
- Reflect on Pearl Legacy
Historical Significance of Pearls
In ancient civilizations, pearls were highly esteemed for their rarity and beauty. They often symbolized wealth, power,
and divine favor. Their use varied across different cultures, reflecting each society’s unique values and beliefs.
Roman Empire
![]() |
In ancient Rome, pearls were prized as symbols of wealth and power, surpassing diamonds in value. Julius Caesar (100–44 BCE) reinforced their exclusivity by restricting their use to aristocrats through sumptuary laws. While Caesar’s reverence for pearls was partly tied to their association with Venus, a goddess he claimed as an ancestor, he also leveraged them as political and personal influence tools.His most legendary gift was Servilia’s pearl, a black pearl valued at 6 million sesterces (equivalent to ~$1.5 billion today), which he purchased as a lavish gesture to his mistress Servilia. |
Ancient China
![]() |
In ancient China, pearls were revered not only for their beauty but also for their supposed medicinal properties. Traditional Chinese medicine documented pearls’ use for over 2,000 years, with early records in texts like Zhou Hou Bei Ji Fang (Jin Dynasty, AD 266–420) and Ben Cao Gang Mu (Ming Dynasty, AD 1578). They were believed to detoxify, soothe nerves, and improve eyesight. Pearl powder was processed for bioavailability, enhancing the absorption of amino acids and minerals. Modern studies note its anti-inflammatory and calming effects. Pearls were also used to create intricate jewelry and were considered a symbol of wisdom and purity. |
Mesopotamia
![]() |
In Mesopotamia, pearls were used in trade and considered a valuable commodity. They were traded across regions, including the Persian Gulf and the Indus Valley. The Abu Dhabi Pearl, discovered on Marawah Island, is the world’s oldest known natural pearl (5800–5600 BCE). It was found in a Neolithic settlement alongside Mesopotamian ceramics and other artifacts. Archaeologists suggest it was traded with Mesopotamia (modern Iraq/Iran) for goods like pottery, reflecting early regional commerce. |
Mesoamerica
![]() |
In Mesoamerican cultures, pearls were ceremonially significant, symbolizing divine favor and ancestral ties, as seen in depictions of wing oyster pendants in Olmec art. While pearls were traded as luxury goods, their primary role was symbolic, reflecting broader societal reverence for iridescent materials. The use of pearls in ancient civilizations highlights their enduring appeal and the diverse ways they were integrated into cultural practices. Each civilization’s unique approach to pearls reflects broader societal values and beliefs, underscoring the multifaceted significance of these natural treasures throughout history. |
Global Influence
Pearls have more than just aesthetic value—powerful myths, trade empires, and global economies have shaped them. This section explores how stories, routes, and riches elevated pearls to their status.
Myths and Legends
Pearls are often enveloped in myths and legends that enhance their allure. In ancient Greece, pearls were believed to be the tears of the gods, while in Hindu mythology, they were associated with the moon and purity. These narratives contributed to the perception of pearls as mystical and divine objects, further elevating their status.
Influence of Trade Routes
Trade routes, particularly the Silk Road and Maritime Routes, significantly influenced the value of pearls. These routes facilitated the exchange of pearls between the East and West, making them a coveted commodity.
The table below illustrates key trade routes and their impact on pearl distribution:
Trade Route | Regions Connected | Impact on Pearl Trade |
Silk Road | Asia to Europe | Indirectly facilitated pearl exchange via Central Asian intermediaries |
Maritime Routes | Persian Gulf to India | Enhanced pearl availability in South Asia via established fisheries and trade hubs |
Spice Routes | Southeast Asia to Europe | Increased demand for exotic pearls in Europe |
Economic Impact
The economic impact of pearls cannot be understated. As a luxury item, pearls contributed to the wealth of regions known for pearl production, such as the Persian Gulf and the coasts of India. The pearl trade enriched local economies and played a role in developing global trade networks.
The multifaceted value of pearls across different cultures is a testament to their enduring appeal and significance. Their historical importance is reflected in the diverse ways they have been perceived and utilized, from symbols ofdivine beauty to markers of social status.
Different Types of Pearls and Their Origins
Pearls are among the most cherished gemstones in the world, but not all are created equal. Their type and origin significantly determine their appearance, quality, value, and environmental impact.
Natural vs. Cultured Pearls
While natural and cultured pearls are esteemed for their beauty and value, they differ significantly in their formation processes, characteristics, and market implications. Understanding these differences is crucial for industry professionals and consumers alike.
Natural pearls form without human intervention. They occur when an irritant, such as a parasite, becomes trapped within a mollusk. The mollusk secretes layers of nacre, a combination of aragonite and conchiolin, around the irritant, eventually forming a pearl. This process is entirely organic and can take several years, resulting in rare and often
irregular pearls.
In contrast, cultured pearls are the result of human intervention. The process involves deliberately inserting a nucleus into a mollusk, typically a small bead or piece of mantle tissue. This stimulates the mollusk to produce nacre layers around the nucleus, forming a pearl.
Cultured pearls can be produced in a fraction of the time it takes for natural pearls to form, and the process allows for greater control over their size, shape, and color.
Aspect | Natural Pearls | Cultured Pearls |
Formation Process | Occurs naturally without human intervention | Involves human intervention to initiate the formation |
Time to Form | Several years | Typically, 6 months to 3 years |
Shape and Size | Often irregular and varied | More uniform and can be controlled |
Rarity | Extremely rare | More common due to controlled production |
Market Value | Generally higher due to rarity | Varies based on quality, but generally lower |
Luster and Nacre Quality | Often exhibit unique luster with thick nacre layers, enhancing durability | |
Color Variations | Natural color depends on the mollusk and the environment | Color can be influenced by the nucleus and the mollusk species |
Environmental Impact | Not directly associated with large-scale farming | Can impact ecosystems; sustainability depends on responsible farming practices |
Understanding these differences not only aids in the appreciation of pearls but also informs purchasing decisions and conservation efforts within the industry.
Major Pearl Harvesting Regions
The global pearl industry is characterized by several key regions renowned for their unique production, each contributing distinct qualities and characteristics to the market.
These regions are primarily distinguished by the type of pearls they produce, which are influenced by local environmental conditions, species of mollusks, and cultivation techniques.
South Sea Pearls
South Sea pearls are predominantly cultivated in the waters of Australia, Indonesia, and the Philippines. These pearls are produced by the Pinctada maxima oyster, known for its large size, which allows for the cultivation of pearls ranging from 9 to 20 millimeters in diameter.
South Sea pearls are celebrated for their exceptional luster and unique color spectrum, which includes white, silver, and gold hues. The warm waters and nutrient-rich environment of the South Seas contribute to the development of these high-quality pearls.
Country | Oyster Species | Pearl Size (mm) | Notable Colors |
Australia | Pinctada maxima | 9-20 | White, Silver |
Indonesia | Pinctada maxima | 9-20 | Gold, Silver |
Philippines | Pinctada maxima | 9-20 | Gold, White |
Japanese Akoya Pearls
Japan is synonymous with Akoya pearls, which are cultivated using the Pinctada fucata martensii oyster. These pearls are typically smaller, ranging from 2 to 9 millimeters, and are renowned for their high luster and perfectly round shape.
The cooler waters of Japan, combined with meticulous cultivation techniques, result in pearls that are highly prized for their classic white color with rose or silver overtones.
Japanese Akoya Pearl Characteristics:
- Size: 2-9 mm
- Luster: High
- Shape: Round
- Color: White with rose or silver overtones
Tahitian Pearls
Tahitian pearls, often black pearls, are primarily produced in French Polynesia. These pearls are cultivated using the Pinctada margaritifera oyster, which thrives in the nutrient-rich lagoons of the region.
Tahitian pearls are unique for their dark body color, ranging from black to gray, with overtones of peacock, green, and blue. The size of Tahitian pearls typically ranges from 8 to 18 millimeters.
Freshwater Pearls
China is the leading producer of freshwater pearls cultivated in various species of freshwater mussels. Unlike saltwater pearls, freshwater pearls are often nucleated with mantle tissue rather than a bead, producing pearls in a wide array of shapes and colors.
The size of freshwater pearls can vary significantly, typically ranging from 4 to 14 millimeters. The diversity in color includes white, pink, lavender, and more.
Freshwater Pearl Characteristics:
- Size Range: 4-14 mm typically, though sometimes can exceed 14 mm
- Shapes: Round, Baroque
- Colors: White, Lavender, Peach
These regions collectively contribute to the diversity and richness of the global pearl market, each offering pearls with distinct characteristics that cater to a wide range of consumer preferences and applications.
Pearl Cultivation Over Time
The evolution of pearl farming has been marked by significant advancements that have enhanced the quality and quantity of pearls produced. These developments have been driven by scientific research, technological innovation, and a growing emphasis on sustainable practices.
Advancements in Nucleation Techniques
One of the most notable advancements in pearl farming is the refinement of the nucleation process. This involves carefully inserting a nucleus, typically a small bead, into the oyster or mollusk to stimulate pearl formation.
Advances in surgical techniques and using more biocompatible materials for nuclei have resulted in higher success rates and improved pearl quality.
Technique | Description | Impact on Pearl Quality |
Traditional Nucleation | Manual insertion of the nucleus | Variable success rates |
Laser-Assisted Nucleation | Precision insertion using laser technology | Higher precision and success |
Biocompatible Nuclei | Use of organic materials for nuclei | Enhanced pearl luster and shape |
In addition to nucleation, oyster breeding and genetic advancements have played a crucial role in pearl farming. Selective breeding programs have been implemented to cultivate oysters with desirable traits such as faster growth rates, disease resistance, and the ability to produce superior luster and color pearls.
Genetic mapping and molecular biology techniques have further enabled the identification of genetic markers associated with these traits, facilitating more targeted breeding efforts.
Sustainable Practices in Pearl Farming
Environmental management practices have also seen significant improvements. Pearl farms now employ sophisticated monitoring systems to maintain optimal water quality, temperature, and nutrient levels, which are critical for oyster health and pearl development.
Using remote sensing technology and data analytics allows for real-time monitoring and adaptive management of farming conditions.
Sustainability has become a central focus in modern pearl farming. Efforts to minimize environmental impact include implementing eco-friendly farming practices, such as reducing waste and preventing overharvesting.
Certification programs and eco-labels have been introduced to promote sustainable practices and assure consumers of the environmental responsibility of pearl products.
Practice | Description | Environmental Impact |
Waste Reduction | Minimizing by-products and recycling materials | Decreased pollution |
Controlled Harvesting | Regulating oyster collection to prevent depletion | Preservation of natural stocks |
Eco-Certification | Adherence to sustainability standards | Consumer confidence in products |
These advancements collectively contribute to the ongoing evolution of pearl farming, ensuring the production of high-quality pearls while maintaining ecological balance and promoting sustainable industry practices.
Technological Impact on Pearl Production
The pearl industry has undergone significant transformation due to technological advancements, which have enhanced the efficiency and quality of pearl production.
One of the most significant technological advancements in pearl production is biotechnology. This has allowed for more precise control over the nucleation process, where a nucleus is inserted into the oyster to stimulate pearl formation.
Producers can achieve higher success rates by optimizing this process and producing more consistent shapes and sizes of pearls.
Key Technological Advancements in Pearl Production:
Technology | Impact on Pearl Production |
Biotechnology | Improved nucleation success rates and pearl quality |
Imaging Technology | Enhanced quality control and grading accuracy |
Water Quality Monitoring | Better environmental management and oyster health |
Automated Sorting Systems | Increased efficiency in pearl sorting and grading |
Imaging technology has also played a crucial role in the pearl industry. Advanced imaging systems, such as X-ray and digital scanning, assess the internal structure of pearls, ensuring that only those meeting specific quality standards are marketed.
This technology aids in accurately grading pearls, which is essential for maintaining market standards and consumer trust.
Water quality monitoring systems have been developed to ensure optimal oyster health and pearl formation conditions. These systems utilize sensors and data analytics to monitor real-time parameters such as temperature, salinity, and pH levels.
By maintaining ideal environmental conditions, producers can reduce mortality rates and improve the yield of high-quality pearls.
Automated sorting systems have revolutionized the efficiency of pearl processing. These systems use machine learning algorithms to sort and grade pearls based on size, shape, luster, and surface quality. Automation speeds up the sorting process and reduces human error, ensuring a more consistent product for the market.
Technology has profoundly impacted pearl production by enhancing the precision and efficiency of cultivation processes, improving quality control measures, and promoting sustainable practices. Advanced water quality monitoring systems can reduce oyster
mortality rates by up to 30%, significantly increasing the yield of high-quality pearls.
These advancements have enabled the industry to meet growing consumer demand while maintaining high-quality standards and environmental responsibility.
Case Study of Sustainable Pearl Farming in the Aru Islands, Indonesia
The Nature Conservancy (TNC) case study offers a compelling example of sustainable pearl
farming in the Aru Islands of Indonesia, showcasing a successful, community-based approach to marine resource management.
This initiative highlights the potential for pearl farming to catalyze broader marine conservation efforts, effectively balancing economic benefits with environmental stewardship.
Key elements of the program include:
- Community Empowerment: Local communities are at the forefront of the project and are empowered to manage their pearl farms sustainably. This approach ensures that local knowledge and traditional practices are integrated into farming, fostering a sense of ownership and responsibility for the marine environment.
- Best Practices: The project promotes implementing best practices in pearl farming to minimize environmental impacts. This includes careful site selection to avoid sensitive habitats, responsible waste management to prevent pollution, and controlled harvesting to ensure the long-term health of oyster populations.
- Market Incentives: The program establishes a market for sustainably produced pearls, thereby increasing their value and creating a long-term economic incentive for conservation. The initiative ensures that conservation efforts are economically viable by connecting local farmers with buyers who value sustainable practices.
The Aru Islands case study illustrates that responsible pearl farming can produce multiple positive outcomes.
- Environmental Conservation: Sustainable farming practices help protect the region’s marine ecosystems, preserving biodiversity and ensuring the health of coral reefs and other critical habitats.
- Economic Development: The project provides local communities with a sustainable source of income, improving their livelihoods and reducing their reliance on destructive practices such as overfishing.
- Social Benefits: The initiative fosters community cohesion and strengthens local governance structures, empowering communities to manage their natural resources effectively.
This case demonstrates how integrating environmental conservation with economic development can be a highly effective strategy for achieving long-term sustainability in the pearl industry. It provides a model for other pearl-farming regions worldwide.
By prioritizing community involvement, promoting best practices, and creating market incentives for sustainability, pearl farming can be transformed from a potentially damaging activity into a force for marine conservation.
Pearls in Art and Literature
Historically, pearls have been significant in art and literature, symbolizing purity, wealth, and beauty. Their unique luster and rarity have made them a subject of fascination and inspiration for artists and writers alike.
In the realm of visual arts, pearls have been prominently featured in numerous iconic paintings. Johannes Vermeer’s “Girl with a Pearl Earring” is one of the most renowned artworks highlighting the allure of pearls.
This painting, often called the “Mona Lisa of the North,” captures the enigmatic beauty of a young girl adorned with a large pearl earring, emphasizing the gem’s elegance and timeless appeal.
Artwork | Artist | Year | Description |
Girl with a Pearl Earring | Johannes Vermeer | c.1665 | A portrait of a young girl wearing a large pearl earring showcases the gem’s allure. |
The Birth of Venus | Sandro Botticelli | c.1486 | Venus emerges from the sea, adorned with pearls, symbolizing purity and beauty. |
Portrait of a Lady | Rogier van der Weyden | c.1460 | Depicts a noblewoman wearing a pearl necklace, highlighting her status and wealth. |
In literature, pearls have been used as powerful metaphors and symbols. In F. Scott Fitzgerald’s “The Great Gatsby,” pearls represent wealth and the superficial nature of the characters’ lives.
Similarly, in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Scarlet Letter,” the character Pearl symbolizes the great price her mother paid for her existence, drawing a parallel between the preciousness of the gem and the child.
Moreover, pearls have been referenced in poetry, often symbolizing purity and perfection. In George Herbert’s poem “The Pearl,” the gem represents spiritual wealth and divine grace, illustrating its deep cultural and spiritual significance across various literary forms.
The enduring presence of pearls in art and literature underscores their multifaceted symbolism and profound impact on human culture. Their representation in these creative fields continues to reflect societal values and the timeless allure of these natural treasures.
Perception of Pearls in Modern Times
Today, while pearls remain a symbol of elegance and sophistication, their accessibility and perception have shifted due to advancements in cultivation and changes in consumer behavior.
Market Value
Several factors, including size, luster, surface quality, and shape, determine the value of pearls. High-quality pearls, particularly those that are large and have exceptional luster, are still considered luxury items.
The table below illustrates the average market value of different types of pearls:
Pearl Type | Average Price Range (per strand) | Luxury Status |
South Sea Pearls | $1,000 – $100,000 | Very High |
Tahitian Pearls | $500 – $20,000 | High |
Akoya Pearls | $300 – $10,000 | High |
Freshwater Pearls | $50 – $5,000 | Moderate |
Consumer Perception
Modern consumers often view pearls as versatile and timeless, suitable for formal and casual occasions. This versatility has broadened their appeal beyond traditional luxury markets.
The perception of pearls as a luxury item is also influenced by branding and marketing strategies that jewelry companies employ, which often emphasize the heritage and craftsmanship of pearl jewelry.
Sustainability and Ethical Considerations
The growing emphasis on sustainability and ethical sourcing in the luxury market has impacted the perception of pearls. Cultured pearls, which are farmed with minimal environmental impact, are often marketed as an eco-friendly luxury
option.
Transparency in the supply chain and adherence to ethical farming practices enhance its luxury status among environmentally conscious consumers.
Pearls Become Popular in Fashion
The emergence of pearls as a fashion trend can be traced back to several pivotal historical periods, each contributing to the gemstone’s enduring allure. The Renaissance marked a significant shift, as pearls became a symbol of status and sophistication, often adorning the garments of royalty and nobility.
The 16th century, often called the “Pearl Age,” witnessed an unprecedented demand for pearls, driven by European exploration and the discovery of new pearl sources in the Americas. This period saw pearls being integrated into elaborate jewelry designs, including necklaces, earrings, and brooches, which were highly sought after by the aristocracy.
In the early 20th century, Kokichi Mikimoto introduced cultured pearls, revolutionizing the industry. This innovation made pearls more affordable and accessible, leading to a democratization of pearl fashion. The 1920s, in particular, saw a surge in the popularity of pearl necklaces, often worn as a staple accessory by women embracing the flapper style.
Today, pearls remain versatile and timeless in fashion, adapting to modern trends while retaining their historical significance.
Famous Figures Play in Popularizing Pearls
Throughout history, numerous prominent figures have played pivotal roles in popularizing pearls, significantly influencing their status as a symbol of elegance and sophistication.
One of the most influential figures in the history of pearls is Queen Elizabeth I of England. Her reign in the 16th century marked a period where pearls were not only a symbol of wealth and power but also an essential element of royal attire.
Queen Elizabeth I was often depicted wearing elaborate pearl necklaces, earrings, and headpieces, reinforcing the perception of pearls as a regal accessory. Her extensive use of pearls set a precedent for their association with royalty and high status.
Figures such as Audrey Hepburn, who famously wore a pearl necklace in the film “Breakfast at Tiffany’s,” have cemented pearls as a timeless fashion statement.
Hepburn’s portrayal of elegance and sophistication contributed to the perception of pearls as an essential accessory for the modern woman.
Influence of Contemporary Fashion Trends
One of the primary drivers of this shift is the innovative use of pearls in contemporary jewelry design. Designers are increasingly incorporating pearls into unconventional settings, combining them with materials such as leather, metals, and gemstones.
Reflect on Pearl Legacy
The story of pearls is one of enduring fascination, innovation, and transformation. Across epochs and empires, pearls have served as emblems of status, vessels of mythology, icons of fashion, and catalysts of commerce. Their journey from ocean depths to royal courts to runways is a powerful testament to humanity’s timeless connection to nature and beauty.
This guide demonstrates how pearls have not merely adorned history—they have shaped it. As the pearl industry evolves through technological advancements and sustainable practices, the luminous legacy of these natural wonders continues toexpand.
Today, pearls transcend traditional roles, embodying timeless charm and modern relevance. Rooted in heritage yet continually reinvented, they embody timeless charm and modern relevance.
For collectors, designers, historians, and consumers alike, pearls offer more than elegance; they offer a legacy worth understanding, preserving, and celebrating.
References
- Bixby, A. (2022, May 4). Pearls of Wisdom: Five Things You May Not Know about Pearls. The Met Store. https://store.metmuseum.org/blog/pearls-of-wisdom-five-things-you-may-not-know-about-pearls
- Song, Y., Chen, W., Fu, K., & Wang, Z. (2022). The application of pearls in traditional medicine of China
and their chemical constituents, pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical research. Frontiers in Pharmacology,
13. https://doi.org/10.3389/fphar.2022.893229 - International Gem Society LLC. (2024, April 28). Pearl Symbolism and Legends – International Gem Society.
International Gem Society. https://www.gemsociety.org/article/history-legend-pearls-gems-yore/ - Mark, J. J., & Amin, O. S. M. (2023). Trade in Ancient Mesopotamia. World History Encyclopedia. https://www.worldhistory.org/article/2114/trade-in-ancient-mesopotamia/
- Archive, H. (n.d.). AncientMesopotamia. History Archive. https://ancientmesopotamia.org/cultures/dilmun
- Abu Dhabi Pearl: The world’s oldest known natural pearl discovered on Marawah Island. (n.d.). Department of
Culture and Tourism Abu Dhabi. https://dct.gov.ae/en/media.centre/news/abu.dhabi.pearl.the.worlds.oldest.known.natural.pearl.discovered.on.marawah.island..aspx - Turner, A. D. (2020). THE OLMEC SPOON RECONSIDERED: MATERIAL MEANINGS OF JADE, NACREOUS SHELLS, AND PEARLS IN
ANCIENT MESOAMERICA. Ancient Mesoamerica, 33(2), 261–277. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0956536120000358 - Sanatan Prabhat. (2022, September 22). Pearls : What should be the Spiritual Perspective when buying ? https://sanatanprabhat.org/english/38149.html
- Paik, L. B. a. C. (2021). Trade and Political Fragmentation on the Silk Roads: The Economic Effects of
Historical Exchange between China and the Muslim East. American Journal of Political Science, 65(1),
115–132. https://www.jstor.org/stable/45415616 - Sustainable Pearls. (2023, October 20). Akoya cultured pearls • Sustainable Pearls. Sustainable Pearls •
Responsible Pearl Farming / Ethical Pearls / Fair Trade Pearls. http://sustainablepearls.org/pearls/akoya-cultured-pearls/ - Edeline, P., Leclercq, M., Luyer, J. L., Chabrier, S., & Droit, A. (2023). Pearl shape classification
using deep convolutional neural networks from Tahitian pearl rotation in Pinctada margaritifera. Scientific
Reports, 13(1). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-40325-z - Non-Bead-Cultured Pearls from Pinctada margaritifera | Research & News. (n.d.). https://www.gia.edu/gia-news-research/non-bead-cultured-pearls-from-pinctada-margaritifera
- Mackenzie, C. L., Raap, M. R., Leduc, S., Walker, C. Y. V., Green, T. J., Kim, E., Montgomery, E. M., Gray,
S. L. M., Long, A., & Pearce, C. M. (2024). Development of a nature-based solution for mitigation of
Pacific oyster summer mortality: use of the intertidal zone to improve resilience to environmental
stressors. Frontiers in Marine Science, 11. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2024.1345493 - Pearl quality factors. (n.d.). https://www.gia.edu/pearl-quality-factor
- Sustainable Pearls. (2023a, October 18). A history of pearls • Sustainable Pearls. Sustainable Pearls •
Responsible Pearl Farming / Ethical Pearls / Fair Trade Pearls. https://www.sustainablepearls.org/pearls/a-history-of-pearls/ - View all posts by Doing History in Public & Doing History in Public. (2023, May 2). Pearly Queens:
Eleonora di Toledo vs. Elizabeth I. Doing History in Public. https://doinghistoryinpublic.org/2023/05/02/pearly-queens-eleonora-di-toledo-vs-elizabeth-i/